Should You Consider a Personal Loan to Repay a 401k Loan?

by Gary Foreman

Pay Off a Personal Loan with a 401k Loan photo

Making a bad decision on a 401k loan could put your retirement savings in jeopardy. So should you take out a personal loan to pay off your 401k loan? A CFP weighs in on how to determine the best financial move for you.

According to the Investment Company Institute, there’s nearly $4.5 trillion in 401k retirement accounts representing about 18% of all retirement assets. But many people for various reasons have taken out a 401k loan.

Even though they’re popular, 401k loans can be confusing. Making a bad decision on a 401k loan could put your retirement savings in jeopardy. So we contacted Certified Financial Planner Jeff Nordin to help us understand 401k loans. Jeff has an MBA from Cornell University, founded CoreFinancialEducation.com and has over 20 years of experience advising clients.

Q: Why are people so quick to take out a 401k loan?

Mr. Nordin: 401k loans seem to be driven by people looking to pay off credit card debt or experiencing an emergency.

People should look to borrow from their 401k only if no other options remain. The two biggest reasons for this are removing pre-tax dollars from your 401k but repaying with after-tax dollars and reducing the earnings power (tax-free) of your retirement money.

That said if your plan allows for loans, you may borrow up to 50% of your vested account balance, or $50,000, whichever is less. Also, employers can put stipulations on what the loan can be used for, and loans must be paid back within five years.

Q: What are some of the reasons that you’d want to repay a 401k loan as quickly as possible?

Mr. Nordin: The single biggest reason is to get those funds back in your 401k growing free of taxes. The power of this over time is a huge ally toward having a sufficient retirement fund down the road.

We can help you gain control of your finances and live better...for less.

Subscribe to Financial Independence, our daily email newsletter. It doesn't cost anything. And, it could make a huge difference in the way you live! Subscribers get Are You Heading for Debt Trouble? A Simple Checklist and What You Can Do About It for FREE!

Your Email:

We can help you gain control of your finances and live better...for less.

Subscribe to Financial Independence, our daily email newsletter. It doesn't cost anything. And, it could make a huge difference in the way you live!

Debt ChecklistSubscribers get Are You Heading for Debt Trouble? A Simple Checklist and What You Can Do About It for FREE!

Your Email:

Q: Some are advocating using a personal loan to pay off a 401k loan, especially since there are so many new lenders like SoFi, Prosper, Lending Club, etc. available. What advantages could there be for the borrower?

Mr. Nordin: The big advantage is paying your 401k back sooner rather than later.

Low rates could be another advantage. Even though you are “paying yourself” the interest (401k loans are typically one or two percent above the prime rate, currently 3.5%), you’re not just paying interest, but also missing out on earning a tax-free return on the borrowed funds. If one expects an 8% return, that 401k loan could be “costing” you 13% or more!

Q: There are always some drawbacks. What’s the downside of using a personal loan to repay a 401k loan?

Mr. Nordin: One real potential disadvantage would be paying a substantially higher interest rate on a personal loan.

Q: Are there any circumstances where the personal loan or 401k loan is always better?

Mr. Nordin: Rate and terms comparable, a personal loan would almost always be superior to borrowing from your 401k.

Q: Are there any questions that the borrower should ask themselves before making a final decision?

Mr. Nordin: The easy-for-me-to-say-to-ask-yourself questions are “Why is it that I need to borrow in the first place?” and “What steps do I need to take to get my financial life in better order?”

Exhaust all options, including personal loans and even borrowing from family, before resorting to a 401k loan.

Reviewed April 2020

About the Author

Gary Foreman is a former financial planner and purchasing manager who founded The Dollar Stretcher.com website and newsletters in 1996. He's the author of How to Conquer Debt No Matter How Much You Have and he's been featured in MSN Money, Yahoo Finance, Fox Business, The Nightly Business Report, US News Money, Credit.com and CreditCards.com. Gary shares his philosophy of money here. Gary is available for audio, video or print interviews. For more info see his media page.

Let us help you achieve your financial goals.

Subscribe to Financial Independence, our daily email newsletter. It doesn't cost anything. And, it could make a huge difference in the way you live!

Debt ChecklistSubscribers get Are You Heading for Debt Trouble? A Simple Checklist and What You Can Do About It for FREE!

Your Email:

Follow Us

We can help you gain control of your finances and live better...for less.

Subscribe to Financial Independence, our daily email newsletter. It doesn't cost anything. And, it could make a huge difference in the way you live!

Debt ChecklistSubscribers get Are You Heading for Debt Trouble? A Simple Checklist and What You Can Do About It for FREE!

Your Email:

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This