Should I Fix It Myself? Or Hire a Pro?

by Gary Foreman

Even in our “throw-away” society, there’s still some repairs that you can do yourself. The trick is knowing which ones to attempt and which to leave to a professional.

Some of my favorite money-saving emails I get are ones like these from people who have figured out how to do a home repair on their own, saving them the high cost of hiring a pro or replacing an appliance:

Dear Dollar Stretcher,
Recently we thought our microwave had died for good. It acted as if it had no power so my husband checked the breaker box and the fuse wasn’t blown. He unplugged it, popped off the top and looked at all the wires and they looked as if all were connected. Then he noticed a fuse in it. He took it out and took it to an appliance store. He was able to buy a cheap replacement fuse, put it in, put the top on, plugged it in and now it’s working again. The guy at the appliance store said they go out once in a while. Saved us the cost of a new microwave.
Joanne H. in Enumclaw, WA

How Can You Decide If You Want To Play Repair Person?

Like Joanne’s husband, I like to try to do some repairs myself.

Part of the attraction is saving money. The other part is curiosity about how things work.

Her story is a common one. Even in our “throw-away” society, there’s still some repairs that you can do yourself. But the trick is knowing which ones to attempt. In some cases a failed repair attempt could actually cost you money or even be dangerous.

So how can you decide whether you want to try to play repair person?

Before deciding whether to attempt a repair you need to ask yourself a couple of questions.

Do You Know What’s Wrong?

The first one is: do you have any idea of what’s wrong?

Some items, especially electronics, are so complicated that it’s almost impossible to try to fix them unless you have special training and tools.

But even on complicated appliances there are some things that you can check. Joanne’s microwave is a perfect example. You don’t need to understand how they cook to know that it needs electricity to work. Anyone can check a cord for bad connections or look for a blown fuse.

What Will You Do If You Can’t Do the Repair?

Next, decide what you would do with the item if you can’t fix it. Would you call in a repair person, buy a new one or live without it?

If you’re going to be forced to buy a new one or live without it, there’s usually not much risk in trying to fix it. Unless you buy expensive parts, the worst that can happen is that you take it apart, can’t fix it and end up throwing away the disassembled pieces.

On the other hand, if you’d call in a repair person, make sure that you don’t make the problem worse with your attempted repair. That can get expensive.

Think Through the Possible Outcomes Before You Get Out the Tools

A boyhood experience showed me how that works. If you’ve ever tried to take apart an old fashioned wind-up watch you know that there’s a point where removing one additional screw will release dozens of springs and gears! And, unless you’re a trained watchmaker, there’s no way to ever get them back together again. Boing! Whoops!!

Fortunately that watch taught me a lesson.

Think through the possible outcomes before you pull out your screwdriver. If you can get into big trouble, you might decide to walk away from a particular challenge. And, that’s okay. Our goal is to save money, not destroy items that a professional could repair.

Do Your Research

Before you attempt any repair, spend a little time thinking about how the item works and what the symptoms are. If you don’t know about the appliance search the internet or YouTube and do a little research. You’d be surprised how many do-it-yourself articles and videos are available.

Many appliances can be broken down into two or three different processes. Breaking the item down into it’s separate functions helps you diagnose the problem. You don’t need to understand everything. Just the basics of the subsystem that’s broken.

A recent challenge with our washing machine is instructive.

It was more than 10 years old and with two children we’ve gotten some fair use out of it. Now it was starting to leak. And the leak was getting worse. After studying it a bit I realized that the leak probably was occurring in either the hoses and mixing valve that let water into the tub, or in the pump section that forces the water out of the tub. If the problem were in the pump assembly the parts could cost more than an old washer was worth.

Fortunately, after removing the cover, I found that the inlet hose was cracked. Do I understand completely how a washer works? No. Just that water must come into the tub and then get out to the drain. An hour’s work and a couple of bucks prevented a major purchase.

There was another lesson from this experience.

A year ago the mixing valve wouldn’t work. And, even though I correctly guessed what was wrong, I couldn’t figure out how to get the cover off of the washer. I had to call in a professional. While he was there I made sure to watch what he was doing. Most repair people are glad to answer a question or two as long as you don’t put them behind schedule. In this case I learned the trick to removing the cover. That sure came in handy this time around.

Friends can be an important resource, too. When you have a problem mention it to your DIY friends. Perhaps they’ve come across a similar problem. They might even be willing to help you with your repair.

Don’t Be Afraid To Fail

One final thought on home repairs. Don’t be afraid to fail. There’s no disgrace in it. Even experienced do-it-yourselfers often find that their skills and tools aren’t up to a repair job. As long as you don’t make a problem worse, you really haven’t lost anything but your time.

And, occasionally you’ll succeed. And when you do, you’ll save some money and also have the satisfaction of knowing that you did it yourself. The only downside is that more items pop up on your project list!

• Troubleshooting Simple Electrical Problems
• How To Perform Your Own Annual Air Conditioner Inspection
• A Budget-Friendly DIY Kitchen Remodel
• How To Avoid a Plumber’s House Call

Reviewed July 2023

About the Author

Gary Foreman is the former owner and editor of The Dollar Stretcher. He's the author of How to Conquer Debt No Matter How Much You Have and has been featured in MSN Money, Yahoo Finance, Fox Business, The Nightly Business Report, US News Money, Credit.com and CreditCards.com.