Second Marriage Finances: What to Do Differently
by Gary Foreman
If your first marriage involved a lot of money fights, take the right steps to prevent those same issues from happening the second time around.
Dear Dollar Stretcher,
I’m about to be married for the second time. We each have kids from a previous marriage. Both of our ex’s caused money troubles. Neither of us want to go through that again. Are there tools we can use to avoid problems? Do you have advice on whether or not we should have joint checking, etc.? We want to do everything we can to make sure that money doesn’t break up our marriage!
Get on the same financial page with premarital financial counseling
You can begin with some premarital financial counseling. Too many couples don’t spend enough time here. Specifically discuss what things about your ex’s financial habits caused problems. This is a great way to learn where your mate is sensitive and for him to understand your hot spots.
Talk about how your parents related to money and what you think about money today. Be open about how you evaluate financial issues. Expect your hubby to be open, too. Insist on honest answers from each other.
Start living better for less.
Subscribe to get money-saving content by email that can help you stretch your dollars further.
Twice each week you'll receive articles and tips that can help you free up and keep more of your hard-earned money, even on the tightest of budgets.
Subscribers receive a free copy of our eBook Little Luxuries: 130 Ways to Live Better for Less.
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.
Determine how daily finances will be handled and how expenses will be covered
You’ll need to discuss how to handle day-to-day finances and decide how different expenses will be covered. One frequently used method is the three checkbook/account system: yours, mine, and ours. It allows for some money that you can use however you wish. It also includes a joint account for your bills.
Decide in advance how much will go into each account. Also, have a discussion as to what you’ll do if the joint account runs short of money. A plan now could avoid an argument later.
You might also want to consider having a wish list. That’s a list that you both contribute to with things that you’d like to spend money on if extra dollars were available.
I’ll assume that you’re both working. That, too, is something that you should discuss prior to saying “I Do.” You’ll need to also discuss whether your paycheck belongs to you or to the family.
Don’t forget to discuss your wills
You’ll also need to consider your wills. A will determines what should happen to your assets once you have passed away. It’s likely that you will already have a will before you enter into the marriage but it may just need amending.
You might want to consider a few key questions, such as, should all children be treated equally? Or will the children from your prior marriage be treated differently from your partner? Who gets control over your home? Do you have any special wishes?
Talk about your retirement accounts
Consider the ones that you bring into the marriage and the ones that you’ll create after you’re married. The tendency will be to look at your IRA or 401k as being your own money since it’s coming from your paycheck, but that can easily cause misunderstandings, especially when you begin withdrawing from the account or consider who the beneficiaries should be.
It’s OK if you argue and disagree about some things
Some of these discussions will be very revealing in terms of how you relate to money and also how you see your blended family.
Don’t be afraid to disagree and even to argue a bit. It’s better to uncover any truly irreconcilable financial differences before the wedding.
You’ll need to find a balance. Keeping your finances too separate can make it harder to become one with your mate. Most relationships, especially marriages, work better when you share some common goals.
On the other side, putting everything together is much tougher in a second marriage, especially if you bring different resources and responsibilities to the marriage.
A few more things to discuss
A major decision will be which items to consider “household” items and which to consider “personal” ones. How you answer may provide insight into how much of yourself you’re willing to invest in the marriage.
You’ll also need to decide if differences in income will affect how much each of you contribute to the joint expenses. That will help you discuss career issues and your standard of living.
Pick a time to revisit all decisions in the future
Plan for a time in the future (6 months? 1 year?) when you’ll revisit the issues. You might even want to take a weekend away from home and the kids. It’s almost certain that you’ll discover some things after you blend your families. Knowing that you’ll have a chance to discuss problems will keep them from growing in significance.
Watch what you model for your children. They’ve already been a part of one failed marriage. How you handle your finances will tell them a lot about the health of your relationship and could affect their own perception of marriage.
Finally, congratulations on your upcoming marriage! May it be stress-free financially!
Reviewed June 2021
About the Author
Gary Foreman is a former financial planner and purchasing manager who founded The Dollar Stretcher.com website and newsletters in 1996. He's the author of How to Conquer Debt No Matter How Much You Have and he's been featured in MSN Money, Yahoo Finance, Fox Business, The Nightly Business Report, US News Money, Credit.com and CreditCards.com. You can read Gary's full bio here. Gary shares his philosophy of money here. Gary is available for audio, video or print interviews.